Spritzenhaus has a ton of beer on tap, and decent bar food. It is big, bright and airy.
Matchless is our usual haunt, small and usually has good music. They have greasy options: fries, wings, etc.
Haven't been to Black Rabbit in a while, but it is small and cozy (a little on the dark side as far as lighting is concerned.)
Pete's Candy Store is similar to Matchless, though if they have food I've never had it.
What say ye @ironchef, @gougetheeyes, @MrsGougeTheEyes?