Hahahahahahahaha @Pugilist!
I'm looking for places near you in Park Slope, and in Manhattan as well, today. Will post a short-list as soon as it is done!
- - - Updated - - -
If ya'll want pizza, Guiseppina's in Brooklyn is fantastic - it's on 6th Ave between 20/21st Sts - South Slope. It's a hike, and I wouldn't expect that those coming from NJ would want to make the hike to it...
Barn Joo (Flatiron) looks good. And, it is in a fairly convenient location for everyone.