Welcome @Abe Froman You've found a great community here. I'm sure you'll get some excellent feedback. There is a good thread around here about what makes a good tattoo: http://www.lastsparrowtattoo.com/forum/general-tattoo-discussion/2396-what-makes-good-tattoo.html
Have a read through that , if you like. I'm not a tattooer, so I am not the right person to offer much advice outside what I have personally experienced. I think you might want to consider avoiding tattoos without outlines. Perhaps someone else here can explain better than me, but I don't think they hold up as well over time. You needn't have massively thick outlines, but I think some is better than none. It sounds like you have done almost everything except get the tattoos! Good luck - getting tattooed is an amazing journey.